ComForCare Home Care
Get Started!
Episode 56 Caregiving and the Generosity Paradox

The Generosity Paradox: How to Help a Parent Without Giving Away Your Future

On the first of every month, $700 moves from your checking account to your mom’s. It covers what her Social Security doesn’t. You set it up two years ago, after she mentioned the electric bill was late again. Since then, you’ve lowered your 401(k) contribution to make room for the transfer, and you’ve stopped bringing it up with your siblings. If someone asked whether you’re a caregiver, you’d probably say no. You’re just helping out.

Maddy Dychtwald, Co-Founder and President of Age Wave, has spent nearly 40 years studying how longer lives are changing families and finances. In a recent episode of ComForConnections, she joined host Tiffany Robinson to discuss new research from Edward Jones and Age Wave on financial caregiving.

One finding stands out: the generosity paradox, in which adult children give more than they can afford to parents who never wanted to be a burden.

What is the generosity paradox?

Across Age Wave’s studies over the years, older adults keep giving the same answer: they don’t want to become a financial burden to their children. The new research found the same feeling among caregivers themselves. 

  • 87% of financial caregivers say they don’t want to become a burden on their own families
  • 81% are willing to reduce their own financial security to support the person in their care

“People are giving from the heart, but oftentimes they’re giving more than they can actually afford,” Dychtwald says.

That giving takes many forms. Among caregivers who make unreimbursed contributions, the report found the average is $8,737 a year. Nearly half of financial caregivers make personal sacrifices to cover the money and time care requires. They cut back on savings, withdraw from retirement accounts, take unpaid leave, or pass up promotions, and some leave the workforce entirely.

How the generosity paradox carries into the next generation

The cost of those sacrifices often shows up years later. A caregiver who pauses retirement contributions at 45 or leaves a job at 55 has less to draw on when their own care needs arrive. That makes it more likely they’ll one day need help from their own children.

“We’ve added years to our lives,” Dychtwald says. “Now we need to make sure those years don’t come at the expense of the next generation’s financial security.”

Women feel this most directly. According to the research, women caregivers spend more hours on care each month than men, and are more likely to reduce their savings or delay their own medical care. Women also live five to six years longer than men on average, Dychtwald notes, so many will need care themselves later in life. “While women are often the architects of everyone else’s well-being, we need to make sure they don’t become the casualties of their own generosity,” she says.

Part of what keeps the cycle going is the way families picture a good caregiver. “We romanticize the idea,” Dychtwald says, of “the person who gives everything for love.”

Deciding what you can realistically give

Dychtwald’s advice starts with a clear look at your own finances before making a major commitment. “Understand, what can you realistically afford?” she says. “Not just this month, but over the next five or 10 years.”

From there, she recommends talking with a financial advisor, involving other family members, and finding out what benefits and professional resources are available. Those family conversations work best early, before a crisis forces quick decisions. Siblings often split the work unevenly. One might provide hands-on care, another might contribute money, and a third might live across the country. Each can feel they’re doing their fair share while defining “fair” differently. Agreeing on roles ahead of time gives everyone the same starting point.

“Remember, caregiving isn’t a competition to see who can sacrifice the most,” Dychtwald says. Financial caregiving in particular, she adds, “is a team sport.”

Bringing in help before you’re overwhelmed

“One of the biggest mistakes families can make is waiting until they’re completely overwhelmed before they even consider getting outside help,” Dychtwald says. She describes professional support as “a strategy for sustainability.” The options are wider than many families realize:

  • A financial advisor can help protect the family’s resources.
  • An elder law attorney can help with legal planning.
  • Professional caregivers can provide hands-on help with daily activities, meals, and companionship.

Hands-on help also affects the financial side of caregiving. When a professional caregiver takes on some of the day-to-day tasks, Dychtwald says, it can allow an adult child or spouse “to stay literally employed, protect their own health… and preserve the relationship” with the person they’re caring for.

Time together can change, too. Visits no longer have to be spent rushing through a checklist of chores. “The greatest gift professional caregiving provides is giving families back the emotional space to be a family,” she says.

Revisiting the plan as needs change

A plan that works when a parent needs help with groceries and a bank account will need to change if mobility, bathing, or dementia care come into the picture. 

Dychtwald recommends that families revisit the plan regularly and talk it through with the care recipient and other relatives. She also suggests bringing in professionals as needs grow. The caregiver’s own health, career, and long-term finances belong in that conversation as well.

“A sustainable care plan has to care for the caregiver as well as for the loved one receiving that care,” she says.

Listen to the full episode of ComForConnections to hear Maddy Dychtwald and Tiffany Robinson talk through more of the research. They cover how to start money conversations with a parent and the one document Dychtwald says every family should have in place. You can also download the full report from Edward Jones.

Considering In-Home Care?
We have your
perfect caregiver.
For care, please fill out the form below.
For employment, please go to careers.

For details on data handling, please visit our Franchisee Privacy Policy here. Message and data rates may apply. The frequency of messages varies. Reply HELP for assistance or STOP to unsubscribe.

or call (800) 886-4044.

Services vary by location. Please contact us to see what services are available in your area.

Over 250 ComForCare Locations Nationwide

We're Here to Answer Your Questions

Each office is independently owned and operated
and is an equal opportunity employer.

© 2026 ComForCare Franchise Systems, LLC.

(click the 'x' to close this pop up)
Considering In-Home Care?
We have your
perfect caregiver.
For care, please fill out the form below.
For employment, please go to careers.

ComForCare is committed to protecting and respecting your privacy.

By checking this box, I agree to receive text messages (SMS) from ComForCare. Message frequency may vary. Message and data rates may apply. You can reply STOP to opt-out at any time. For assistance, reply HELP. Check our Terms and Privacy Policy

For details on data handling, please visit our Franchisee Privacy Policy here. Message and data rates may apply. The frequency of messages varies. Reply HELP for assistance or STOP to unsubscribe.

or call (800) 886-4044.

Services vary by location. Please contact us to see what services are available in your area.